The price performance of the markets this month was progressive in comparison to February. The market cap of the whole crypto industry started hovering over $2T shortly before March came to an end. This month also witnessed crypto’s highest correlation with tech stocks, as seen in the chart below. Bearing in mind that the closer it is to 1, the higher the correlation, and that the closer it is to 0, the lower the correlation, the connection between Bitcoin and S&P 500 is still relatively very low. There have been a lot of developments in the Ethereum network, riling up hype in its ecosystem. One of the biggest moves is the long-anticipated proof-of-stake migration, which has shown a visible impact on Ethereum’s price performance, up 15.5% from last month.
In this report, we will explore the macro factors driving the markets, on top of which is the war waging between Russia and Ukraine. We will also lay out our propositions on regulatory movements, initiatives as well as technological developments in the crypto industry.
March started with the cancellation of what would have been the world’s first state-run airdrop. The Ukrainian government decided to withdraw from issuing fungible tokens, announcing it would drop some NFTs to support the Ukrainian army.
On March 30, the first sale of Ukraine’s “Museum of War'' was made. The Ukrainian government partnered with Fair.xyz, a one-stop shop for NFTs, to build a timeline of collages and images documenting the Russian invasion of Ukraine sold as tokens on the Ethereum blockchain. The government expects to raise at least $2M from its Museum of War, featuring 5,000 to 7,000 NFTs priced at around $450 each.
Moreover, Ukraine’s deputy minister of digital transformation said that crypto is playing a significant role in Ukraine’s defense. Although the amount ($71.8M) of donations made in crypto is just a small fraction in comparison to those made in fiat, Ukrainian authorities highlighted that the speed and ease of use of crypto transactions are what really helped the war-ridden nation.
That being said, the crypto use case in the Ukrainian plight for humanitarian aid appears to be two-fold. The Museum of War aims to preserve the memory of the real events of that time, spread truthful information among the digital community in the world, and collect donations simultaneously. This is not the first example in this history-preserving use case in the crypto industry.
Arweave is a crypto project that now has over 41M files uploaded to document the ongoing crisis. Describing itself as a global, permanent hard drive built on the blockchain, Arweave is a decentralized storage protocol designed to provide scalable and permanent on-chain data storage sustainably. At 21Shares, our thesis has been that the use cases of blockchain technology and Web 3 tools echo louder in the wake of geopolitical conflicts. We have laid out our thesis on Arweave in the fifth issue of our State of Crypto, of which you can get a copy here.
On the same philanthropic note, Uniswap added a new “Donate to Ukraine” feature to encourage ETH donations to the war-ridden country. The feature automatically exchanges any of Uniswap’s listed tokens to ETH for Ukraine.
On March 7, Coinbase announced that it had blocked more than 25,000 wallet addresses linked to Russian individuals or entities who are suspected of having engaged in illicit activity. Similarly, but with users based in another sanctioned state, OpenSea deactivated Iranian-based accounts without prior notice or explanation, on the back of the escalating conversation about sanctions. Moreover, two fundamental pieces of the Ethereum ecosystem, Infura and MetaMask, are restricting access to users in certain geographical areas, shying away from giving any specific details.
At 21Shares, as noted in our State of Crypto magazine, the decentralization of the crypto web development layer will be key to unlocking the full potential of Web3. There are competitors and alternatives to Infura such as Pocket Network attempting to become the TCP/IP of Web3 node infrastructure – a multi-chain relay protocol that incentivizes RPC nodes to provide dApps and their users with unstoppable Web3 access.
On March 11, as the invasion entered its fourth week, news came out that high-net-worth Russians attempted to liquidate billions of dollars of crypto last week through Dubai crypto companies. A week after, Michael Chobanian, founder of KUNA Exchange, told US senators in a hearing about the role crypto-assets play in the pursuit of illicit finance that there are a lot of Russians in and outside Russia who rely heavily on crypto. These Russians represent the opposition to Putin’s regime, who will be negatively affected if legislation is drafted to exclude Russian users altogether, killing the opportunity to have an opposition to bring down this regime. Chobanian denied that the Russian government could evade sanctions using crypto-assets, explaining that it’s virtually impossible to transfer large amounts of money from fiat to crypto-assets.
Back in 2020, our Director of Research Eliezer Ndinga pointed out that leaders from Iran, Malaysia, Turkey, and Qatar were looking at cryptocurrencies as substitutes for the US dollar in bilateral trade agreements, according to this article. In a conference held on March 24, Russia’s Duma Committee on energy chair revealed the country’s intentions to be more lenient with its allies, selling its oil to Turkey and China for lira, yuan, and Bitcoin. Whereas, for countries imposing sanctions on Russia, that would be either gold or rubles. With the UK and the US already holding a ban on Russian oil, the EU is left in a pickle. Russian oil fields supply Europe with a quarter of its oil, which gives reason for its division on the fueled matter.
On March 15, it was reported that Saudi Arabia is considering accepting yuan when selling oil to Chinese customers as oil surges amid the Russo-Ukrainian conflict. This foreshadows the scenario we have long anticipated at 21Shares, an effort to hedge against the dollar's hegemony with the rise of central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).
On March 16, former Bank of Japan executive Hiromi Yamaoka nodded to our thesis. He said that sanctions imposed on Russia could encourage more countries to look at CBDCs as a tool to counter the dollar's dominance in the global financial system. A month before Yamaoka’s statement, a week before the invasion, Russia had in fact begun piloting its digital ruble, following in China’s footsteps which had started piloting its digital yuan back in January.
Also, under sanctions, it was reported on March 18 that Qatar has been investigating the possibility of launching a digital Qatari rial and issuing digital bank licenses.
On March 25, the Bank of England (BoE) announced its partnership with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Media Lab Digital Currency Initiative, or DCI, on a joint twelve-month research project on CBDCs. The new project is for research purposes only and is not intended to develop an operational CBDC, according to the BoE.
The US is also taking big steps towards a digital dollar as part of President Joe Biden’s Executive Order (EO) published on March 9, which we’ll delve deeper into in the next section.
In the US, Biden signed an EO titled Ensuring Responsible Development of Digital Assets, assigning government agencies to a number of tasks.
- The Department of Commerce is asked to develop a framework for interagency international engagement with foreign counterparts to create an international forum to enhance the adoption of digital assets and standardized rules.
- National security agencies were asked to provide supplementary annexes on cyber security and make sure that US cryptocurrency laws align with those of the country’s allies to ensure international frameworks and partnerships are responsive to risks.
- The Treasury, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) among others are assigned to gather recommendations to develop a policy for the digital asset sector.
- The Treasury Secretary is assigned to conduct a report on the future of money and payment systems. The report should delve into the impacts of digital assets on economic growth, financial growth and inclusion, national security, and the extent to which technological innovation may influence that future.
During the aforementioned hearing session on crypto’s role in illicit activities, Senator Elizabeth Warren introduced a bill targeting Russian crypto use. The Digital Asset Sanctions4Compliance Enhancement Act features co-sponsorship from 10 other Democratic senators, including the Foreign Relations and Agriculture Committees leaders, but not the Banking Committee Chair Sherrod Brown. If Warren’s bill is passed, the presidential administration would be required to identify "any foreign person" operating a crypto exchange or facilitating digital asset transactions. Another provision would authorize the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) to identify users transacting with more than $10,000 in crypto.
In the UAE, Dubai rolled out its first legislation on cryptocurrencies, and is now in the amendments and approval phase. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and CBDCs are not covered in the Dubai Virtual Asset Regulation Law, which calls for the ban of “algorithmic tokens,” which interfere with supply and demand to control price and “privacy tokens,” designed to obscure token holders and trading patterns.
Whereas in Europe, the European Parliament Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs and the Committee on Civil Liberties adopted on March 31, with 93 votes to 14 and 14 abstentions, their position on draft legislation strengthening EU rules against money laundering and terrorist financing. All transfers of crypto-assets will have to include information on the source of the asset and its beneficiary, information that is to be made available to the competent authorities.
Patrick Hansen from blockchain firm Unstoppable DeFi warned that the regulation would require crypto service providers, such as crypto exchanges, to continue collecting personal data related to transfers made to and from unhosted wallets and to also verify the accuracy of the data gathered.
As mentioned before in our previous newsletters, tightening the regulatory fist on the crypto industry might jeopardize some projects but will definitely pose an opportunity to others. The rise of AML-focused legislations will inevitably encourage crypto b2b projects to make AML compliance in the crypto industry a walk in the park. We’ve already seen the likes of Chainalysis among others already tapping on that blindspot of the market.
Britain has also been brewing some plans for its crypto industry. In the coming weeks, the British government is expected to reveal crypto regulation plans with a special focus on stablecoins. Although plans are still not made public, sources told CNBC that they are likely to be favorable to the industry, providing legal clarity for a sector that has so far been mostly lacking in regulation.
Ethereum saw its final public variation of its merge testnet preceding the final Proof-of-Stake (PoS) switch - dubbed Kiln - launch on March 24. In that view, the migration of the largest smart-contract network to a PoS network is soon to become a feasible reality by Q2 of 2022. This enthusiasm was felt as Ethereum’s balance on exchanges fell to its lowest point since 2018, as hedge-funds like 3AC had a solid bullish case to bet on its compelling future, seeing they deposited more than $110M worth of ETH into Lido’s liquid staking service. The switch should also enrapture traders and hedge funds as they expect the network’s yields to swell to somewhere from 10-15%, notably as the fees garnered for miners (base-fees) will now be reallocated towards stakers.
On the other hand, Avalanche had grounds for its rally rooted in the fact that Terra’s infamous anchor money-market protocol will now be deployed on top of the network through its wormhole integration. This should fend-off native users from having to take their funds off-chain and instead leave it within the premises of Avalanche.
Digital payments giant Stripe announced on March 10 that it’s re-entering the crypto industry with a bundle of use cases that would give customers access to tools and APIs that facilitate buying and storing crypto tokens, cashing out, and even trading NFTs. Stripe is also providing crypto businesses with compliance tools akin to Know Your Customer (KYC) to prevent fraud and illicit activities. FTX partnered with Stripe to improve their KYC protocols and to also provide payment services for the exchange. FTX and FTX US users will be able to buy crypto using debit cards and direct bank transfers via Automated Clearing House transactions.
Stripe is offering fiat payments API integration for crypto businesses to process crypto-to-fiat currency payments. These on-ramps will enable both fiat deposits and withdrawals for crypto exchanges, as co-founder John Collison put it on Twitter. Stripe’s brand new crypto tools will be available for its users in up to 180 countries, providing them with over 135 cryptocurrencies with fiat currencies.
We’ve seen many thought and market leaders, like David Heinemeier Hansson and Warren Buffet, change their minds about crypto; Stripe is one of them. In 2018, Stripe decided to stop supporting Bitcoin in payments, as they were “less useful” as such. On March 10, they updated the 2018 announcement with a disclaimer announcing their change of heart and their partnership with FTX.
At 21Shares, we’ve always reiterated the thesis that increased institutional adoption is one of the effective ways for mass adoption, but in the case of Stripe, the roles were somehow reversed. With the size of Stripe’s scope, this may come as bad news for smaller crypto projects that worked to appeal to L1s and dApps to streamline their payments infrastructure as well as their KYC and KYB workflows. While in fact, Stripe is only raising the bar, rejuvenating the competition, which only means that the ecosystem’s skin is about to get a lot thicker.